The second in a series of posts elaborating on my list of skills to use when dealing with difficult personalities.
When I say “managing up” I’m talking about the org chart - you know, that thing someone in HR uses powerpoint boxes and lines to show just who is the boss of who. Many of us end up somewhere in the middle of these charts, with Chairman and CEO at the very top and Intern at the very bottom. The “up” in managing up means all those people above you on the org chart. Not just your own supervisor, although that’s a good place to start.
And yep, you read that right. I’m suggesting you manage your manager. When I say manage, I don’t mean manipulate. I don’t mean micro-manage. I mean you need to communicate on a regular basis with your manager. Don’t wait for your manager to walk by your desk and check up on you. Don’t wait for them to ask for a progress report. Take some initiative.
First, find a good time to ask them about their job. If you’re on friendly terms with them, lunch may be the perfect opportunity. If you’re new to the organization or don’t feel comfortable going to lunch with your boss, just ask them as they walk by your desk sometime, or ask if you can schedule a meeting with them if you have to. Most importantly, be friendly about it - not confrontational. You’re not asking them to justify their position (middle managers can be a little sensitive about that sometimes), you’re just making conversation and getting to know them better.
Try something like this. “Hey, you know… I think I’m getting a handle on what my job entails. Tell me about what you do.” Almost everyone likes to vent a little to someone who might have some idea of what they’re dealing with. Encourage them. If you can, find out what they’re struggling with, or what they consider the most boring or difficult part of their job. Find out what they enjoy, too. Take notes if you need to.
What are you going to do what this information? First let me tell you what you’re not going to do. You’re not going to tell anyone else about it. You’re not going to gossip about it with other supervisors or your coworkers. You’re not going to use this information to get your supervisor in trouble in any way. Even if they talk about their likes and dislikes while hanging out in the public break room, it’s not your business to pass it around. This act alone - respecting their privacy - will help them learn to trust you. (Trust shows up later on my list… notice how they all fit together?)
What you should do with this information is compare it with your own job description and see where it overlaps. For instance, many supervisors have somewhere on their todo list something like, “keep the team on track” or “make sure my fte’s are doing what they’re supposed to.” Even if they don’t mention it when you talk to them - it’s implied in the title of supervisor/boss/manager. Many supervisors also have to make reports to their own supervisors about how things are going.
Real Life Example Where Managing Up Saved My Job:
During one conversation as described above, I found out my supervisor had to fill out a specific form every week. This form was submitted to their boss, and that’s how the higher-ups knew what we were accomplishing in the trenches. At first my boss would only show me a blank version of this paperwork. I was surprised. I was sure there were meetings where our progress was discussed. I didn’t realize someone had turned this into a paperwork churn where these reports were filed away in manila folders every week.
Then one day my boss let me see a report that had already been filled out. I felt sick to my stomach and cried myself to sleep when I got home that night. Seriously. Not because my supervisor said something bad about me on the form. Not at all. But I had accomplished some huge things that week - and these big milestones weren’t listed on the form. In the report, it looked like all I had done that week was read email and take a phone call or two. This was how my supervisor viewed my work! The rest of my time might as well have been spent filing my nails. The next day I worked up the courage to ask about it.
My boss confessed to forgetting those milestones were reached that week. “Wasn’t that last week?” I said no. They dug up the previous week’s report and sure enough - it wasn’t on that report either. “Huh. I’ll add that. Thanks! This makes it look like we got all kinds of things done!”
Well, that’s because we did. And I had emailed about it when I got it done. What I learned the hard way was that my boss had a memory like a sieve. Nothing stayed in there for more than five minutes unless it was written down on a post-it (email was too easy to delete). Looking on the bright side - I was glad I found this out relatively early in my career with this person as my supervisor.
So here’s what I did. I managed up.
“So, boss. When do you usually fill out that form every week?”
“Well, we have a staff meeting every Friday at 3:00pm where we turn in the forms and discuss them. So I usually start working on it at 2:30 on Friday afternoon.”
So during the week, whenever I finished anything worth mentioning, I made a note of it on a single post-it. Instead of a todo-list, it was a done-list. On Friday each week, when I got back from lunch, I got into a habit of looking over the list to see if I forgot something. Then I would stop by my boss’ desk and stick the post-it in the middle of the computer monitor. My name was on it, and a quick “call if you have questions” with my phone number (mind like a sieve, remember?).
At first, I got no response from my boss. I kept up dropping off the done-list, even though it wasn’t something I had been assigned. It wasn’t technically part of my job to compile a list of milestones reached each week. About a month later my supervisor came out of the weekly staff meeting all smiles. Stopping by my desk, the comment was something like… “Our team is making all the others look bad - we’re kicking ass these last few weeks!”
Well, in reality the team as a whole was still just chugging along as always. The difference was, I was doing a better job of “managing up.” I was helping my supervisor do their job, and it took me all of 5 minutes each week. Not a huge time-suck, but it got me huge results. I later found out these forms ultimately determined things like my salary increases, promotions and perks like travel. And through this form, I was not just making my own supervisor’s job easier - I was making my boss’s boss’s boss look better, too. These reports moved way up the company in some cases.
Since then I’ve had many more bosses, and many more people with “dotted line” responsibility for me. Taking a few minutes to find out how I can make their work easier/more pleasant/more effective has made me a ‘right hand man’ several times, and prepared me for taking on management responsibilities myself.
And it never ends - even when you’re the owner of a small business, you’re still managing up. Suddenly it’s clients and investors who are above you on your org chart, and managing them appropriately can make the difference between thriving and dying.